RideGearGuideTrailer & Towing › Best Trailer Spare Tire Carriers
TRAILER & TOWING • BUYING GUIDE

Best Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

Five focused picks with compatibility, capacity and real-world tradeoffs.

See the Top Picks Explore Trailer & Towing
QUICK VERDICT

Start with wheel bolt pattern

Verify wheel bolt pattern first, then compare tire size and mount location. System compatibility and the lowest applicable rating matter more than headline capacity.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Top Picks

Use the cards for a quick shortlist; the individual sections explain the tradeoffs behind each ranking.

Best Overall

Thule Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

★★★★★ 9.5/10

Balanced for wheel bolt pattern and tire size.

CHECK PRICES
Best Premium

Yakima Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

★★★★★ 9.2/10

Premium focus on tire size.

CHECK PRICES
Best Value

CURT Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

★★★★★ 9.0/10

Value pick for mount location.

CHECK PRICES
Best Specialized

Reese Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

★★★★★ 8.8/10

Specialist choice for load rating.

CHECK PRICES
Best Alternative

Tekonsha Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

★★★★★ 8.6/10

Alternative strong in corrosion resistance.

CHECK PRICES
#1
Best Overall

Thule Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

★★★★★ 9.5/10

Why it made the shortlist: This option fills the best overall role when wheel bolt pattern is a major priority. Compare wheel bolt pattern, tire size and mount location against the exact vehicle, trailer, rack or trip use.

Verify current dimensions, ratings, included hardware, installation requirements and tire size before ordering.

Best for
Wheel Bolt Pattern-focused buyers.
Watch for
Mount Location and exact compatibility.
CHECK PRICES
#2
Best Premium

Yakima Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

★★★★★ 9.2/10

Why it made the shortlist: This option fills the best premium role when tire size is a major priority. Compare wheel bolt pattern, tire size and mount location against the exact vehicle, trailer, rack or trip use.

Verify current dimensions, ratings, included hardware, installation requirements and mount location before ordering.

Best for
Tire Size-focused buyers.
Watch for
Load Rating and exact compatibility.
CHECK PRICES
#3
Best Value

CURT Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

★★★★★ 9.0/10

Why it made the shortlist: This option fills the best value role when mount location is a major priority. Compare wheel bolt pattern, tire size and mount location against the exact vehicle, trailer, rack or trip use.

Verify current dimensions, ratings, included hardware, installation requirements and load rating before ordering.

Best for
Mount Location-focused buyers.
Watch for
Corrosion Resistance and exact compatibility.
CHECK PRICES
#4
Best Specialized

Reese Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

★★★★★ 8.8/10

Why it made the shortlist: This option fills the best specialized role when load rating is a major priority. Compare wheel bolt pattern, tire size and mount location against the exact vehicle, trailer, rack or trip use.

Verify current dimensions, ratings, included hardware, installation requirements and corrosion resistance before ordering.

Best for
Load Rating-focused buyers.
Watch for
Wheel Bolt Pattern and exact compatibility.
CHECK PRICES
#5
Best Alternative

Tekonsha Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

★★★★★ 8.6/10

Why it made the shortlist: This option fills the best alternative role when corrosion resistance is a major priority. Compare wheel bolt pattern, tire size and mount location against the exact vehicle, trailer, rack or trip use.

Verify current dimensions, ratings, included hardware, installation requirements and wheel bolt pattern before ordering.

Best for
Corrosion Resistance-focused buyers.
Watch for
Tire Size and exact compatibility.
CHECK PRICES

How to Choose Trailer Spare Tire Carriers

  • Wheel Bolt Pattern: verify this against the exact vehicle, trailer, rack system or road-trip use.
  • Tire Size: verify this against the exact vehicle, trailer, rack system or road-trip use.
  • Mount Location: verify this against the exact vehicle, trailer, rack system or road-trip use.
  • Load Rating: verify this against the exact vehicle, trailer, rack system or road-trip use.
  • Corrosion Resistance: verify this against the exact vehicle, trailer, rack system or road-trip use.
Important: Never exceed the lowest-rated component in the towing system. Verify vehicle tow rating, receiver, hitch, ball, trailer GVWR, tongue weight, brakes and tire ratings, and follow the vehicle, hitch and trailer manufacturers' setup procedures.

Frequently Asked Questions

How should I choose trailer spare tire carriers?

Start with wheel bolt pattern and tire size. Those factors usually eliminate incompatible choices before price or convenience features.

Which specification matters most?

Use wheel bolt pattern as the first filter, then compare tire size and mount location for the exact vehicle, trailer or trip.

What is a common buying mistake?

Buying from headline capacity alone without checking wheel bolt pattern, the lowest system rating and installation clearances.

When is a premium option worth it?

When the extra cost materially improves tire size, durability, security, safety, setup consistency or long-term usability.

What should I verify before ordering?

Confirm dimensions, mount location, current ratings, included hardware and compatibility with every interface in the system.

Why are there five recommendations?

Five distinct buyer roles provide a useful shortlist without turning the article into a repetitive catalog.

What safety or compatibility issue matters most?

Never exceed the lowest-rated component in the towing system. Verify vehicle tow rating, receiver, hitch, ball, trailer GVWR, tongue weight, brakes and tire ratings, and follow the vehicle, hitch and trailer manufacturers' setup procedures.

Final Verdict

Eliminate options that fail wheel bolt pattern, then compare tire size, mount location and the full installation or ownership tradeoffs.

CHECK CURRENT OPTIONS
Affiliate disclosure: RideGearGuide may earn from qualifying purchases. Specifications, fit and ratings can change; verify current manufacturer information before purchase.
Scroll to Top